For centuries, across vast swathes of Asia, Africa, and the Middle East, people have turned not to plastic and nylon for oral hygiene, but to a simple, frayed twig from the Salvadora persica tree. Known as miswak (or siwak, sewak), this “chewing stick” is more than a tool—it’s a tradition steeped in culture, religion, and natural medicine. Touted for its antibacterial properties and accessibility, it’s a staple in millions of daily routines.
But a pressing question has lingered in dental circles: could this natural alternative be contributing to gingival recession—the gradual wearing away of gum tissue that exposes tooth roots, leading to sensitivity, aesthetic concerns, and increased risk of decay?
A new systematic review published in the Journal of Herbal Medicine sifts through 41 years of global research to find an answer. The conclusion? It’s complicated. While miswak has clear benefits, improper or frequent use may pose a significant risk to gum health for some users.
What is Gingival Recession?
Before diving into the miswak debate, it’s crucial to understand the condition in question. Gingival recession is the process where the margin of the gum tissue surrounding the teeth wears away or pulls back, exposing more of the tooth or its root.
“It’s like the soil erosion around a tree,” explains Dr. Nadia Suleman, lead author of the review from James Cook University. “Once the protective gum layer recedes, the sensitive root is vulnerable. This can lead to tooth sensitivity, increased risk of cavities on the root, and in severe cases, tooth loss.”
Globally, recession is surprisingly common, affecting about 50% of the population, regardless of oral hygiene standards. Causes are multifactorial, including aggressive brushing, genetics, thin gum tissue, and inflammation.
The Miswak Method: Natural Doesn’t Mean Gentle
The miswak isn’t used like a modern toothbrush. A stick is typically chewed at one end to separate the fibres, creating a natural brush. Users then employ a pen-like grip to scrub their teeth, often focusing on the front and chewing surfaces. Its appeal is multifaceted:
- Natural Antimicrobials: It contains compounds like fluoride, silica, tannins, and flavonoids that fight plaque-causing bacteria.
- Mechanical Cleaning: The fibrous bristles scrub away debris.
- Cultural & Religious Significance: Its use is encouraged in Islamic tradition and ingrained in many cultures.
- Accessibility & Cost: It’s affordable and doesn’t require toothpaste or water on the go.
However, this very design may be its downside. The bristles can be stiff and abrasive. Without a standardized “soft” option or a small head designed for gentle gumline cleaning, the potential for mechanical trauma is high, especially with a vigorous horizontal scrubbing technique.
What the Research Revealed: A Tale of Two Outcomes
The review analysed 13 studies from 1983 to 2024, encompassing 6,315 individuals from Saudi Arabia, Sudan, Tanzania, Indonesia, Nigeria, and beyond. The findings were far from unanimous, painting a picture of a complex relationship.
Table 1: Key Findings from the Miswak & Gingival Recession Review
| Study Highlight | Key Finding | Implication |
|---|---|---|
| Highest Recession Reported (Eid et al., 1990) | 67.85% of miswak users had recession vs. 41.67% of toothbrush users. | Suggests a strong potential link with improper use. |
| No Recession Found (Saha et al., 2012; Yasmin et al., 2024) | Some studies found no significant difference in recession between miswak and toothbrush users. | Indicates technique and user factors are critical. |
| Tooth Wear & Loss | Multiple studies found increased anterior tooth wear and higher mean tooth loss among long-term miswak users. | Points to abrasiveness as a major concern. |
| Technique is Key (Saleh Muhammad et al., 2017) | 65% of users who used miswak for over 1 year with incorrect technique had recession. | Highlights education as the solution, not necessarily abandoning the practice. |
| Plaque Control Benefit | Several studies confirmed miswak’s effectiveness in reducing plaque and gingivitis. | Reinforces its value as a legitimate oral hygiene aid. |
The data shows a spectrum. On one end, studies like Eid et al. (1990) found alarmingly high rates of recession among miswak users. On the other, research like Yasmin et al. (2024) found no clinical evidence that miswak caused more recession than a standard toothbrush.
The Deciding Factors: Why Some Users Experience Recession
The discrepancy isn’t random. The review identified clear risk factors that turn this natural tool into a potential hazard:
- Aggressive Technique: Horizontal “scrubbing” is the biggest culprit. It directly traumatizes the delicate gumline.
- Frequency & Duration: Using miswak multiple times a day (some reported 3x daily) or for long periods (over a year) increases cumulative abrasive damage.
- Fibre Texture: Fresh, stiff miswak sticks are more abrasive than softened, worn-in ones. The type of plant also matters, with S. persica being the most studied but not the only variety used.
- User Age & Anatomy: Older users and those with naturally thin gum tissue or pre-existing gum inflammation are more susceptible.
- Lack of Access to All Surfaces: Miswak often fails to clean inner (lingual) and between-tooth (interdental) surfaces effectively, allowing plaque to build up and cause inflammation that weakens gum attachment.
Table 2: Risk vs. Benefit Profile of Miswak Use
| Aspect | Potential Benefit | Potential Risk (with improper use) |
|---|---|---|
| Plaque Control | Effective antimicrobial action reduces plaque. | Ineffective technique leaves plaque in hard-to-reach areas. |
| Gum Health | Can reduce gingivitis (gum inflammation). | Abrasion can cause gingival recession and attachment loss. |
| Tooth Structure | Silica may help remove stains. | Causes significant tooth wear, especially on front teeth. |
| Cost & Access | Highly affordable, no need for toothpaste. | Requires proper technique to be safe, which is often not taught. |
| Environmental Impact | 100% biodegradable, sustainable. | N/A |
A Path Forward: Honouring Tradition with Modern Knowledge
The research doesn’t call for the abandonment of miswak. Instead, it’s a clarion call for education and standardization.
“The issue isn’t the miswak itself, but the lack of standardized, evidence-based guidance on how to use it safely,” says Dr. Suleman. “We need to bridge traditional practice with modern preventive dentistry.”
Recommendations for Safer Use:
- Gentle Technique: Use a gentle, vertical or circular motion at a 45-degree angle to the gumline, not aggressive horizontal scrubbing.
- Moderate Frequency: Limit use to once or twice daily to reduce cumulative abrasion.
- Complement, Don’t Replace: Consider using miswak in conjunction with a soft toothbrush and fluoride toothpaste for a complete clean, especially for interdental surfaces.
- Choose Wisely: Opt for medium-soft sticks and allow the tip to soften in water before use.
- Regular Check-ups: Users should have regular dental visits to monitor for early signs of recession or wear.
The Bigger Picture: Cultural Sensitivity in Oral Health
This review underscores a critical gap in global oral health: the need to respectfully integrate evidence-based dentistry with long-standing cultural practices. Public health campaigns in regions where miswak is prevalent must move beyond promoting only the modern toothbrush and instead provide culturally competent guidance on safe traditional practices.
“Dismissing miswak outright is neither practical nor respectful,” the authors note. “The goal is to optimize its use so communities can preserve their traditions without compromising their oral health.”
Conclusion: An Informed Choice
The story of miswak is a powerful reminder that “natural” doesn’t automatically mean “safe” or “gentle.” Like any tool, its impact depends entirely on how it’s used.
The gingival recession risk associated with miswak is real but preventable. It is largely a product of technique, not an inherent flaw. For millions, the miswak is more than a brush; it’s a link to heritage. By marrying that tradition with the gentle techniques of modern dentistry, users can protect their gums while honouring their past.
Reference: here
Other Articles:
