For the world’s 1.8 billion Muslims, Ramadan is a month of spiritual reflection, self-discipline, and community. But new research reveals that the mental health effects of this annual fast are far more complex than previously understood — and they affect men and women in strikingly different ways.
This study published in Scientific Reports followed 284 young Israeli Muslim adults through five assessment points: before Ramadan, during the first week, during the fourth week, and at one week and four weeks after the fast ended. What researchers found challenges simple narratives about fasting and mental health.
“Ramadan fast can lead to short-term and long-term improvements in mental distress symptoms, but also to transient decrease in the quality of life,” write authors Dr. Mahmood Sindiani and Dr. Maria Korman. “These changes, however, do not lead to closing the gaps between genders in these parameters — women will still present more distress symptoms than men.”
The Two-Stage Mental Health Improvement
The study used the Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Scale (DASS-21) to measure psychological distress across the five time points. The results showed a clear pattern: mental health improved in two distinct stages.
Table 1: Mental Health Improvements After Ramadan Fasting
| Measure | Statistical Finding | Significance |
|---|---|---|
| Global Distress | Significant decline across 5 time points | p < 0.001 |
| Depression | Improved primarily in first week | p < 0.001 |
| Anxiety | Improved in first week and post-Ramadan | p < 0.001 |
| Stress | Improved in first week and post-Ramadan | p < 0.001 |
| Gender Difference | Females consistently higher distress | p < 0.001 |
The first significant improvement occurred during the first week of Ramadan — a rapid response that researchers attribute to the spiritual practices, structured lifestyle, and heightened sense of community that characterize the holy month.
“The structured lifestyle during the fasting period, focusing on spiritual activities, regular prayers, and a heightened sense of community were suggested to improve emotional regulation and reduce psychological distress,” the authors explain.
The second improvement happened after Ramadan ended, when participants returned to normal routines. This post-fasting boost may reflect “the psychological relief experienced when normal daily routines are resumed, including usual physical activity, eating and sleeping behaviors, and especially, restored sleep duration and timing.”
The Gender Gap: Women Face Greater Challenges
Throughout the study period, women consistently reported higher levels of psychological distress than men — a finding consistent with broader research showing women generally experience more anxiety and depression. But the Ramadan fasting period revealed additional gender-specific patterns.
During the middle of Ramadan (between the first and fourth weeks), women experienced a significant increase in distress scores, while men did not. This suggests that women may be more vulnerable to the cumulative physical and social demands of fasting.
Table 2: Gender Differences in Mental Health During Ramadan
| Time Point | Finding | Significance |
|---|---|---|
| Throughout study | Females higher distress than males | p < 0.001 |
| Mid-Ramadan (B to C) | Females: distress INCREASED; Males: no change | p = 0.046 |
| Depression | Females consistently higher | p = 0.002 |
| Anxiety | Females consistently higher | p = 0.001 |
| Stress | Females consistently higher | p < 0.001 |
| Quality of Life | Females lower at multiple time points | p < 0.05 |
The clinical relevance of these findings is striking. The proportion of participants scoring above normal thresholds for depression, anxiety, and stress decreased significantly from before Ramadan to the first week of fasting. However, by the end of Ramadan, women showed higher rates of clinically significant depression and anxiety compared to men — gaps that persisted even after the fast ended.
The Quality of Life Paradox
Perhaps most intriguing is what the study revealed about quality of life (QoL). Despite improvements in mental health symptoms, participants’ self-rated quality of life actually declined during Ramadan — particularly among women — before recovering after the fast.
This creates a fascinating paradox: people felt less depressed, anxious, and stressed, yet rated their overall life satisfaction as lower.
What explains this disconnect? The researchers point to social pressures. During Ramadan, work and study hours decreased for most participants — 40.8% reported reducing their load by two or more hours daily. Yet social pressures increased for 36.5% of participants, and nearly two-thirds expressed a desire to reduce social commitments without altering spiritual aspects of the month.
“Social time pressure, defined as the misalignment between endogenous circadian rhythms and socially imposed schedules, may represent a key mechanism that may explain sex-dependent differences in QoL,” the authors write.
In other words, women may bear a disproportionate burden of increased social obligations during Ramadan — preparing meals, managing household duties, hosting gatherings — that diminishes their quality of life even as their mental health symptoms improve.
Why This Matters: 1.9 Billion People and Counting
With nearly 2 billion Muslims worldwide, understanding how Ramadan affects mental health has enormous public health implications. The study’s repeated-measures design — tracking the same individuals across five time points — provides unprecedented insight into the temporal dynamics of fasting’s psychological effects.
“This is the first large-scale within-subject study that investigated the effects of Ramadan fasting on mental distress symptoms and quality of life of young Muslims using five distinct assessment time-points,” the researchers note.
The findings have practical implications for healthcare providers, employers, and policymakers in both Muslim-majority and Muslim-minority contexts. Many countries adjust work hours and academic schedules during Ramadan, yet these policies are “rarely informed by empirical psychological data.”
“Our results, showing reduced distress but transient declines in self-rated quality of life, especially among women, underscore the need for gender-sensitive approaches to social burden reduction during fasting periods,” the authors conclude.
Beyond Symptom Reduction: The Bigger Picture
The study contributes to the growing field of nutritional psychiatry and mind-body interaction research. Ramadan represents a unique natural experiment — a population-wide, annually recurring behavioral intervention affecting nearly 2 billion people.
“Ramadan involves simultaneous changes to eating schedules, sleep-wake timing, social demands, and spiritual engagement, making it a rare real-world model for studying multisystem adaptation,” the researchers explain.
This complexity means that simple measures of symptom reduction don’t capture the full picture. The divergence between improving mental health symptoms and declining quality of life “reveals that population-wide rituals produce complex, multidimensional effects not captured by symptom measures alone.”
What This Means for Muslims Observing Ramadan
For Muslims preparing for next Ramadan, these findings offer both reassurance and guidance. The fast is associated with genuine improvements in depression, anxiety, and stress — benefits that can last for weeks after Ramadan ends.
But the research also highlights the importance of managing social pressures, particularly for women. The participants’ own preferences offer a clue: most wanted to reduce social commitments without altering spiritual practices.
This suggests that communities might support fasting members by creating space for spiritual reflection while reducing expectations around social obligations — allowing people to experience the mental health benefits of Ramadan without the quality-of-life costs.
Looking Forward: What Researchers Still Need to Learn
The study opens numerous avenues for future research. Does the pattern hold in different cultural contexts? How do longer or shorter fasting hours affect outcomes? What specific mechanisms — hormonal, neurological, behavioral — drive the observed changes?
The researchers also acknowledge limitations. The sample consisted primarily of young students, which may not generalize to older populations. The single-item quality of life measure, while practical for field surveys, may not capture the full complexity of well-being.
Most importantly, the study cannot determine whether Ramadan builds lasting psychological resilience or merely produces temporary adaptation. “Establishing Ramadan as a resilience intervention requires studies measuring coping mechanisms directly and tracking responses to subsequent stressors across multiple years,” the authors note.
Conclusion: A Month of Complex Blessings
For centuries, Muslims have experienced Ramadan as a time of spiritual renewal and community connection. This research confirms that the month also offers measurable mental health benefits — reducing depression, anxiety, and stress in ways that persist after fasting ends.
But it also reveals that these benefits don’t come without costs. The social pressures that accompany Ramadan — particularly for women — can temporarily diminish quality of life, creating a complex trade-off that communities and policymakers would do well to address.
As the researchers conclude, understanding these dynamics “holds policy relevance for health systems, educational institutions, and workplaces operating in Muslim-majority and Muslim-minority contexts.” By designing supportive environments that reduce social time pressure, we might help more people experience the full psychological benefits of this ancient practice.
Reference: here
Other Articles.
