Home / Quran Research / Learning by Heart: The Hidden Strengths of Qur’an Memorisation

Learning by Heart: The Hidden Strengths of Qur’an Memorisation

Summary

A scholarly paper challenges a common Western assumption: that memorising a text without understanding every word is pointless. Bill Gent of the University of Warwick and Abdullah Muhammad of the Quran Study Group in London published the study in the journal Religions on 11 July 2019. Their focus is Qur’an memorisation, yet their questions touch every classroom.

The background is simple. Muslims believe the Qur’an came in Arabic over 23 years, and they say the Prophet Muhammad memorised each part and recited it to others. Therefore, learning verses by heart has stayed central to Muslim life. Every Muslim recites Arabic verses in the five daily prayers, and some people complete hifz, which means memorising the whole book. Because most Muslims speak other languages at home, many reciters know the sound of the words better than their literal meaning.

Outsiders have criticised this practice for nearly two centuries. In the 1840s, a British traveller mocked the noise of a boys’ class in Egypt. In 1915, an American missionary dismissed the method harshly. Even today, some educators lump it together with rote learning and call it outdated.

The authors do not defend memorisation at all costs. Instead, they offer five lenses. First, scholars of New Literacy Studies show that literacy takes many forms, including faith literacy, where accurate reading and recitation matter most. Second, meaning has layers, because people can feel understanding through sound and not only through translation. Third, Western culture has long valued memory, from nineteenth-century poetry lessons to today’s Poetry by Heart competition. Fourth, recitation carries emotional power, and researchers in Indonesia describe it as part of everyday life. Fifth, small studies in England suggest that young Muslims who memorise the Qur’an may gain focus, discipline and study skills.

The evidence comes from two projects. In one, Gent interviewed 19 huffaz, people who know the whole Qur’an by heart. In the other, he and a Swedish colleague worked with 27 students aged 15 to 17 in north-east London. Participants reported sharper memory, easier revision, patience and better routines. However, the studies are small, and people described their own experiences. Consequently, the results suggest benefits rather than prove them.

Muslims themselves do not speak with one voice. The medieval thinker Al-Jahiz urged a balance between reflection and memory. Modern writers such as Ziauddin Sardar and Abdullah Sahin question heavy reliance on memorisation. Meanwhile, a British hafiz and teacher in the paper explains how learning the meaning of the first part of the Qur’an improved his recall. He wants his children to treat hifz as a starting point, not a finish line.

In the end, the authors call for balance. They reject both a blanket defence and a blanket dismissal. Memory and understanding can work together, and the best classrooms may offer both. Above all, the paper asks readers to learn why a community keeps its traditions before they judge them.


Memorising Without Understanding? Why Scholars Say the Practice Is Not Pointless

A 2019 academic paper asks readers to look beyond a quick verdict on Qur’an memorisation. Its five lenses reveal a richer story about memory, meaning and learning.

A Debate That Surprises Many Readers

Picture a child who can recite hundreds of pages by heart but cannot translate a single line. To many people in the West, that sounds pointless. However, a scholarly paper argues that this quick verdict on Qur’an memorisation misses a great deal.

Bill Gent of the University of Warwick and Abdullah Muhammad of the Quran Study Group in London wrote the paper. It appeared in the journal Religions on 11 July 2019. In it, the two authors ask why Muslims around the world memorise and recite the Arabic Qur’an, even though most do not speak Arabic.

Importantly, the authors do not offer a blanket defence. Instead, they invite readers to view the practice from five different angles before judging it. Moreover, they admit that real concerns exist, and they stress that Muslims themselves disagree about the right balance.

The topic reaches well beyond religion. Teachers, parents and policymakers all wonder how children learn best, and memorisation sits at the centre of that debate. As a result, the paper speaks to anyone who cares about education, culture and fairness.

Why Muslims Learn the Qur’an by Heart

Muslims believe the Qur’an came to the Prophet Muhammad in Arabic over the last 23 years of his life. According to tradition, he memorised each part and recited it to his community, and they then repeated the same steps for others. Therefore, many regard the Prophet as the first hafiz, a word that carries the sense of guarding and preserving.

Today, every Muslim learns some Qur’anic verses in Arabic. For example, each of the five daily prayers includes recitation, starting with the opening chapter, the Fatihah. Consequently, memorisation is a practical need as well as a spiritual habit.

Some Muslims go further and complete hifz, the memorisation of the entire Qur’an. In length, the text compares to the Christian New Testament. Reciters must also follow the traditional rules of recitation, known as tajwid. Because the community counts hifz as a shared duty, it is enough that some people do it for everyone to fulfil the obligation.

Meanwhile, the language gap is real. For most Muslims worldwide, Arabic differs from the language they speak at home. Thus, a child may recite fluently without knowing each word’s meaning. This gap lies at the heart of the debate, and it explains why outsiders react with surprise.

Why Critics Push Back

Outsiders have voiced doubts for a long time. In the 1840s, the British traveller James Augustus St John visited a boys’ class in Alexandria, Egypt. He described pupils rocking back and forth while shouting verses, and he compared the noise to the labourers of Babel.

Later, in 1915, the American missionary Samuel Zwemer went further. He claimed that thousands of Muslim boys knew the whole Qur’an yet could not explain the first chapter in everyday language. Clearly, his tone was harsh, and the paper links such remarks to Christian criticism of Islam.

Modern critics sound gentler, but the doubt persists. For instance, the children’s author Michael Rosen wrote in 2017 that reading exists to understand what you read. Meanwhile, some textbooks suggest the practice is a leftover from a time before widespread literacy. As a result, many Westerners lump memorisation together with rote learning, or learning “parrot-fashion.”

The authors take these views seriously. Nevertheless, they argue that the critics rely on a narrow idea of what reading, meaning and learning are. The next five sections test that idea, one lens at a time.

Table 2: Five Lenses at a Glance

LensMain ideaEveryday example
1. Many literaciesReading has more than one valid formReciting Latin in church worship or Arabic in prayer
2. Layers of meaningMeaning goes beyond literal translationFeeling moved by a recitation you cannot translate
3. The West memorised tooMemorisation has deep Western rootsThe Poetry by Heart competition
4. The power of soundSound carries emotion beyond wordsOpera sung in a language the audience does not know
5. Benefits for young peopleMemorising may support school and life skillsRevising notes by repeating them aloud

Lens One: More Than One Kind of Literacy

The first lens comes from New Literacy Studies. Its founder, Brian Street, challenged the idea of a “great divide” between reading societies and oral ones. Moreover, he warned that this idea can shape who holds power in society. Therefore, he argued, there is no single form of literacy, but many.

Building on this, the educator Andrey Rosowsky described “liturgical” or “faith” literacy. In this form, communities pass a revered text in a special language from one generation to the next. Latin in the Catholic Church fits the description, and so does Qur’anic Arabic.

Here, children learn to decode and recite the text without needing a word-for-word translation. Instead, the value lies in accurate reading, beautiful recitation, faithful memory and skilled performance. Furthermore, Rosowsky says these skills help shape a young person’s identity.

He also offered a vivid image. The “Rolls-Royce” version of reading, in which decoding comes with full attention to meaning, is not the default everywhere. In faith settings, he suggests, decoding alone is enough. Some scholars have faulted parts of his work. Still, the authors judge his main point well made.

Lens Two: What Does “Meaning” Really Mean?

The second lens asks what “meaning” actually means. Rosowsky notes that, for Muslims, reciting is an act of worship rather than a way to gather information. Consequently, Muslims often use “read,” “pray” and “worship” almost interchangeably when they talk about the Qur’an.

The scholar William Graham pushes this further. He separates “discursive” understanding, which follows the literal content, from “non-discursive” understanding, which comes through hearing and speaking the text. Importantly, he answers with an emphatic no when he asks whether only the highly educated can reach the Qur’an’s meaning.

Other researchers agree. Kristina Nelson writes that “the Qur’an is not the Qur’an unless it is heard.” Likewise, Anna Gade prefers “affirmation” over “comprehension” to describe what many listeners experience.

None of this means word-for-word understanding is unwelcome. In fact, many Qur’an teachers across history have said the ideal is to grasp as much meaning as possible. Yet they also treat that ideal as one goal among several, not as the only test of success. Therefore, the authors urge readers to widen their definition of understanding.

Lens Three: The West Has Memorised Too

The third lens turns the camera on the West. Today, memorisation often gets a bad press there. Historically, however, it enjoyed great respect.

Ancient teachers prized memory as part of oratory. Later, early modern thinkers such as Giordano Bruno and Matteo Ricci built whole systems for storing and recalling knowledge. Meanwhile, famous figures from Thomas Cromwell, who knew the New Testament by heart, to Winston Churchill earned praise for their memories.

In Britain, schoolchildren memorised poems daily until the early twentieth century. In the United States, the habit lasted even longer, according to the scholar Catherine Robson. Her book Heart Beats shows how reciting poems shaped ordinary lives.

Modern examples abound. For instance, the annual Poetry by Heart competition draws many thousands of British students. Similarly, actors learn long scripts as a daily duty. The actor Alec McCowen spent sixteen months learning St Mark’s Gospel and then performed it for two hours. He said he understood the text fully only after he had learned it. Interestingly, that remark suggests memorising can lead to meaning, rather than replace it.

Lens Four: The Power of Sound

The fourth lens focuses on sound. According to the authors, the effect of recitation is greater than the sum of its grammatical parts. Therefore, reading a translation on paper can leave out much of what listeners experience.

Scholars who spend time in Muslim communities say recitation fills daily life. In Indonesia, for example, researchers Anna Gade and Anne Rasmussen describe the sound of the Qur’an as an ever-present part of the everyday soundscape.

Even outsiders feel it. The priest Alan Billings recalled meeting a young imam in Sheffield who spoke no English. When the imam began to recite, old men around him wept, because they believed they were hearing the speech of God. Likewise, a non-Muslim academic later recalled that the beauty and rhythm of the Arabic coloured his love for the scripture.

Finally, Rosowsky compares the experience to opera and choral music. Audiences and singers often enjoy works in languages they do not know, and the meaning still comes across. In short, understanding can arrive through the ear as well as the dictionary.

Lens Five: Hidden Benefits for Young Learners

The final lens looks at evidence from young people. Because few studies have asked Muslim children about their own experience, Gent and colleagues have run small ethnographic projects.

In one, Gent interviewed 19 huffaz in England. Most said memorising the Qur’an had affected their lives. For example, one man felt it sharpened his brain, another said it helped him study at university, and a third said he could recall medical notes and car routes easily.

In another project, Gent and the Swedish researcher Jenny Berglund worked with 27 Muslim students aged 15 to 17 at a large school in north-east London. Many said Qur’anic memorisation supported their schoolwork. One student revised by repeating notes the way he repeats verses, while another credited it for high marks in German speaking tests.

Beyond memory skills, students named patience, perseverance, humility, focus and a daily routine. However, these studies are small, and participants described their own experience. Therefore, they suggest benefits rather than prove them.

Muslims Do Not Speak With One Voice

The paper stresses that no single Muslim position exists. The medieval thinker Al-Jahiz urged a balance, warning that students who neglect reflection or memory both lose out. Today, writers such as Ziauddin Sardar and Abdullah Sahin voice doubts about leaning too heavily on memorisation.

The authors then share a personal case study: a British Muslim who is a hafiz, a teacher and a parent. He memorised the Qur’an in his late teens, but he also learned the word-for-word meaning of the first part, which let him grasp about a third of the text. Moreover, knowing the meaning helped him recall difficult verses.

He wants his own children to do hifz as a starting point, not a finish line. His daughter now learns meanings and attends monthly Qur’an seminars at a nearby university college. At the same time, he questions the heavy focus on huffaz leading Ramadan prayers, and he sees it as a waste of opportunity.

To back his view, he cites the medieval scholar Ibn Taymiyyah, who wrote that books exist to be understood. Nevertheless, he says recitation without understanding is not meaningless. In short, he sees value in both, and he wants them to travel together.

What This Means for Schools and Society

The conclusion is careful. The authors say a blanket defence of memorisation would neither work nor fit the evidence. Most people agree real issues exist in how it is taught. Instead, they call for a layered response.

First, accept that many valid literacies exist. Second, unpack what “meaning” and “understanding” involve. Third, remember the proud place of memorisation in Western culture. Fourth, respect the emotional power of sound. Finally, weigh the growing evidence of benefits for young Muslims.

The stakes are social as well. Since the attacks of 9/11, the authors note, some public voices have linked rote learning with extremism, and Islamophobia has risen. Yet madrasas vary widely, from southeast Asia to elsewhere, and the balance between memory and understanding has been disputed throughout Islamic history.

For readers, the message is simple. Before dismissing a tradition, learn why people keep it. Moreover, the best classrooms may combine memory with understanding, so children gain both the words and their meaning. In short, nuance beats a quick verdict.

Reference: Gent, B., & Muhammad, A. (2019). Religions, 10(7), 425. Open access under a Creative Commons licence. https://doi.org/10.3390/rel10070425

Sign Up For Daily Newsletter

Stay updated with our weekly newsletter. Subscribe now to never miss an update!

[mc4wp_form]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Flag Counter

About Us

By the grace of Allah Azza wa Jalla https://muslimscientist.net/ was founded by a group of Muslim scientists committed to bridging the gap between modern science and Islamic principles. By publishing articles grounded in peer-reviewed scientific research, we aim to contribute to the advancement of civilization while remaining true to the ethical and spiritual framework of Islam.

Support & Contact: Us

muslimscientistnet2025@gmail.com

Sign Up for Daily Newsletter

Name
Email
The form has been submitted successfully!
There has been some error while submitting the form. Please verify all form fields again.