Home / Basic of Islam / Jihad in Islam: The Misunderstood Word Behind the Headlines

Jihad in Islam: The Misunderstood Word Behind the Headlines

Summary

Few Arabic words cause as much confusion as jihad. This news feature, built on reference works, Muslim scholars and legal rulings, explains jihad in Islam and shows where experts disagree.

The Arabic root means to strive or make an effort. Encyclopaedia Britannica calls jihad a meritorious struggle and notes that people in the West have often mistranslated it as “holy war.” Muslim scholars describe several kinds of jihad: struggle against the ego, struggle against the devil, effort with the tongue and pen through teaching and writing, and, in the narrowest sense, armed struggle regulated by law.

A well-known saying contrasts the “lesser” and “greater” jihad. Many hadith specialists judge that report weak, and some modern scholars say the idea arose later. Even so, scholars such as Surkheel Sharif argue that other evidence still gives the inner struggle primacy. At the same time, he warns that this must not erase the legal tradition of armed jihad.

Islamic law treats armed jihad as tightly regulated. A key Qur’anic verse allows fighting those who fight believers and forbids aggression. According to Britannica, classical jurists said only the legitimate ruler could proclaim military jihad, and they forbade attacks on civilians and property. Jurists also treated it as a duty of the community rather than of each person, and they allowed truces.

History adds complications. Many premodern jurists allowed wars of expansion, and critics cite those rulings today. Many modern Muslim thinkers instead limit armed action to self-defence and see older rulings as products of their time. Movements such as the 1804 Sokoto caliphate also used the word for political goals.

Modern militants such as al-Qaeda have claimed the word for attacks, so mainstream scholars pushed back. In 2004 and 2005, Jordan’s King Abdullah II launched the Amman Message and convened more than 180 scholars. They recognised eight schools of law, said only qualified scholars may issue fatwas, and condemned takfir, the practice of branding Muslims unbelievers.

In Indonesia, the Indonesian Ulema Council issued Fatwa No. 3 of 2004 after a wave of bombings. It declares terrorism forbidden, says suicide bombing is not jihad, and separates destructive terrorism from jihad aimed at reform. Researchers note that attacks still occurred afterwards, so the fatwa is one tool among many.

The takeaway is simple. Jihad means striving, most of its forms involve no weapons, and mainstream teaching ties armed jihad to legal limits. Yet disagreements remain, so readers should check who is speaking and which sources they cite.


Jihad in Islam: The Misunderstood Word Behind the Headlines

Few words travel as far from their meaning as jihad. Reference works, Muslim scholars and legal rulings paint a richer and more contested picture than most headlines do.

A Word Everyone Knows, and Few Understand

Few Arabic words spark as much confusion as jihad. Headlines often use it as shorthand for violence, while many Muslims use it to describe daily moral effort. Consequently, people talk past each other.

This article explains jihad in Islam by drawing on reference works, Muslim scholars and legal rulings. It also shows where experts disagree, because the topic is not simple. Moreover, it looks at how scholars in Jordan and Indonesia responded when extremists used the word to justify attacks.

Why does this matter now? Misreading one word can shape how neighbours, classmates and colleagues see each other. In addition, Muslims themselves argue over how the tradition applies today. Therefore, a careful explanation helps both Muslims and non-Muslims discuss the subject with more fairness.

First, the basics. Next, the debates. Finally, the responses. Along the way, two short tables keep the key ideas and dates in view, and readers need no background in religion to follow along.

What the Word Actually Means

The Arabic root of jihad means to strive, struggle or make an effort. According to Encyclopaedia Britannica, the word describes a meritorious struggle, and its exact meaning depends on context. The same source notes that people in the West have often translated it wrongly as “holy war.”

Some Muslim writers agree that the phrase misleads. For instance, the teacher Abu Amina Elias points out that classical Muslim scholars did not use that label. Instead, they described jihad as a broad idea that covers worship, charity and the purification of the heart, as well as the rules of just war.

The Qur’an itself uses the root in many settings. Britannica points out that one verse speaks of striving by means of the Qur’an against opponents in Mecca, which suggests a verbal and intellectual effort. Meanwhile, other verses mention fighting, and later jurists gave those verses detailed legal rules.

In short, the word has layers. A believer who resists anger, a teacher who explains the faith, and a soldier in a defensive war could all, in theory, claim the word. However, each case carries different rules, and Muslims debate which uses are legitimate.

Four Faces of Striving

Classical scholars sorted jihad into types. The fifth-century Islamic scholar al-Raghib al-Asbahani listed three: striving against a visible enemy, against the devil and against the self. Later, Ibn al-Qayyim listed four: against the self, the devil, disbelievers and hypocrites.

The inner struggle, called jihad al-nafs, targets the ego and false desires. It also includes the effort to keep up prayer, fasting, charity and remembrance of God. Scholars call this inner effort mujahadah.

Struggle with the tongue and the pen involves teaching, preaching and writing. According to Elias, even jihad against so-called hypocrites usually means writing refutations, not fighting. Likewise, Britannica describes the ways of the tongue and hand as verbal defence and right action.

Armed struggle, known as qital or jihad al-sayf, is the narrowest category. Scholars regulate it with strict rules, which later sections explain. Therefore, most categories of jihad involve no violence at all.

Table 1: Forms of Jihad at a Glance

FormWhat it meansEveryday example
Inner struggle (jihad al-nafs)Resisting the ego, vices and false desiresControlling anger, keeping up prayer and fasting
Struggle against evil influenceResisting temptation and corruptionRefusing dishonest gain
Struggle with tongue and penTeaching, preaching and writingExplaining the faith, writing a rebuttal
Right action (the “hand”)Doing good and defending justice by deedsServing the community
Armed struggle (qital, jihad al-sayf)Regulated military force, bound by legal rulesDefence of a community under attack

The Greater and Lesser Jihad Debate

Many people have heard the phrase “greater jihad,” meaning the inner struggle. It comes from a report in which the Prophet Muhammad tells returning fighters that they have come back from the lesser jihad to the greater one.

However, scholars dispute the report’s strength. According to Surkheel Sharif of the Yaqeen Institute, classical hadith specialists judged it weak, and Ibn Taymiyyah said it had no basis. Similarly, one essay reports that some modern scholars, including David Cook, argue that the idea of a greater jihad arose later.

Even so, many scholars say the meaning stands on firmer evidence. They cite Qur’anic verses on purifying the soul and other sayings that praise the one who strives against his own ego. As a result, Sharif concludes that the inner struggle has primacy even if the famous report is weak.

Crucially, he also warns against two misreadings. One uses the phrase to wave away armed jihad as unimportant, while the other ignores the legal limits on war. In his view, both distort the tradition. Readers should note that this is one scholar’s argument, and others weigh the evidence differently.

When Armed Jihad Is Allowed

Islamic law treats armed jihad as a regulated matter, not a free-for-all. A key Qur’anic verse, 2:190, tells believers to fight those who fight them while forbidding aggression. Therefore, many Muslim writers describe defence against attack as the core case.

Classical jurists added rules. According to Britannica, only the legitimate leader of the Muslim state, usually the caliph, could proclaim military jihad. Furthermore, jurists forbade attacks on civilians and the destruction of property, citing statements of the Prophet.

In addition, jurists generally treated jihad as a duty of the community as a whole, not of every individual. A scholar quoted by Sharif adds that this contrasts with the personal duty to struggle against one’s own ego, which binds every responsible Muslim at all times.

Moreover, jurists allowed truces and peace treaties and permitted forces to withdraw when badly outnumbered, as an analysis in the Middle East Quarterly notes. Some contemporary Muslim authors go further and say war must be a last resort, never driven by gain, revenge or ambition. Because rules differ among schools and eras, readers should treat any short summary as a simplification.

A Long and Contested History

History complicates the picture. Britannica explains that classical jurists mostly worried about state security and the defence of Muslim lands. Yet many premodern jurists later allowed wars of expansion, and some treated a refusal to accept Muslim rule as a kind of aggression.

Under those expansionist rulings, non-Muslims could accept Islam, accept Muslim rule and pay a special tax, or face fighting unless a treaty protected them. Critics today point to such rulings when they argue that classical law was expansionist.

Other voices disagree. In the Middle East Quarterly, one analysis argues that jurists wrote their law of jihad after the conditions it described had passed. Meanwhile, many modern Muslim thinkers read the Qur’an as a whole and limit military action to self-defence, which leads them to treat many classical rulings as products of their time.

History also offers examples of movements that called their wars jihad. For instance, Usman dan Fodio’s campaign in West Africa created the Sokoto caliphate in 1804, according to Britannica. Therefore, the word has served many political goals, and historians judge each case on its own facts.

How Extremists Borrowed the Word

Modern militants have claimed the word for themselves. A Malaysian academic article notes that al-Qaeda and similar groups waged what they called a global jihad against Muslim nations and the West. As a result, many outsiders now link the word with terror.

Mainstream scholars reject that link. In particular, they argue that deliberately targeting civilians has no place in legitimate jihad, because the classical rules protect noncombatants. Furthermore, Sharif accuses extremists of reading verses on fighting without the legal context found in the manuals of Islamic law.

Extremist groups often rely on takfir, the practice of declaring other Muslims unbelievers. According to King Abdullah II of Jordan, this label then serves to justify violence against people who disagree. In addition, such groups often issue religious rulings without the training that scholars require.

Two simple points follow. First, the same word can describe a charity worker’s patience or a gunman’s claim. Second, the label alone proves nothing, so readers should ask who is using it and under what rules.

Table 2: Key Dates and Numbers

Date or numberWhat it means
3 typesAl-Raghib al-Asbahani’s classification: visible enemy, devil, self
4 typesIbn al-Qayyim’s classification: self, devil, disbelievers, hypocrites
1804Usman dan Fodio’s campaign creates the Sokoto caliphate in West Africa
16 Dec 2003Indonesian fatwa commission gathering decides on a terrorism fatwa
24 Jan 2004MUI Fatwa No. 3 of 2004 on terrorism is finalised
Nov 2004King Abdullah II of Jordan launches the Amman Message
Jul 2005Amman conference of about 180 scholars issues three points
8 schoolsSunni, Shia and Ibadi schools of law recognised at Amman

The Scholars Answer Back: The Amman Message

Jordan’s King Abdullah II launched the Amman Message in November 2004 to clarify what Islam is and is not. Then, in July 2005, he convened a conference in Amman. Reports put attendance at roughly 180 scholars from 40 to 45 countries, depending on the source, and the king said they represented all eight traditional schools of Islamic law.

The scholars made three points. First, they recognised the validity of eight schools of Sunni, Shia and Ibadi law. Second, they said only qualified scholars may issue fatwas, which exposed many extremist rulings as illegitimate. Third, they condemned takfir.

The Associated Press, as republished by Al Jazeera, reported that the initiative urged Muslims to reject extremism, embrace moderation and tolerate other religions. Meanwhile, a commentator in Islamica Magazine called the event a moment when mainstream scholars treated terrorism as a theological problem and not only a security one.

Supporters therefore see the statement as a landmark. Even so, a declaration cannot stop every attack, and the next section shows what happened in Indonesia.

Indonesia’s Response: The MUI Fatwa on Terrorism

Indonesia, with its large Muslim population, faced its own wave of bombings in the early 2000s. In response, the Indonesian Ulema Council (MUI) issued Fatwa No. 3 of 2004 on terrorism. A national gathering of its fatwa commission decided the matter on 16 December 2003, and the fatwa was finalised on 24 January 2004.

The fatwa declares terrorism haram, which means forbidden, and states that suicide bombing is not jihad. Moreover, it separates the two ideas. Terrorism is destructive and lawless, whereas jihad aims at reform, even when it involves fighting.

Leaders have repeated the message since. MUI chairman Miftachul Akhyar has said that suicide bombers do not earn martyrdom. In addition, MUI has said it backs legal action against terrorism suspects, including when police arrested a member of its own fatwa commission.

Nevertheless, researchers note that attacks continued in Indonesia despite the fatwa. Consequently, the fatwa works as one tool among many, alongside policing, education and community work. Even so, it gives ordinary Muslims a clear religious answer when recruiters misuse the word jihad.

What Readers Should Take Away

The evidence points to three lessons. First, jihad means striving, and most of its forms involve no weapons. Second, mainstream teaching ties armed jihad to legal limits, although history shows that jurists and rulers applied the idea in different ways. Third, leading Muslim scholarly bodies reject extremists as spokesmen for the tradition.

Still, honest reporting must admit disagreements. Scholars dispute the authenticity of the famous greater jihad report, argue over how far classical rulings fit the modern world, and debate who has the authority to call a war. Therefore, no single article can settle the question.

For everyday readers, practical habits help. Check who is speaking, look for the religious or legal sources they cite, and compare them with recognised scholarly bodies. Moreover, avoid treating any single speaker, whether a militant or a critic of Islam, as the voice of all Muslims.

Above all, remember that language shapes understanding. When we learn what a word meant to those who coined it, we speak with more accuracy and more respect. In short, informed readers resist both easy fear and easy reassurance.

Sources consulted: Encyclopaedia Britannica, “jihad” (britannica.com/topic/jihad); Surkheel Sharif, “Is Islam a Conquest Ideology? On Jihad, War, & Peace,” Yaqeen Institute (yaqeeninstitute.org); Abu Amina Elias, “Jihad in Islam: War and Peace, Justice and Mercy” (abuaminaelias.com); Middle East Quarterly, “What Does Jihad Mean?” (meforum.org); Amman Message website and King Abdullah II’s 2005 remarks (ammanmessage.com, kingabdullah.jo); Al Jazeera/AP, “Muslim scholars move to curb fatwas,” 7 July 2005; MUI Fatwa No. 3 of 2004 (mui.or.id) and reporting by Tirto, Detik and NU Online.

Tagged:

Sign Up For Daily Newsletter

Stay updated with our weekly newsletter. Subscribe now to never miss an update!

[mc4wp_form]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Flag Counter

About Us

By the grace of Allah Azza wa Jalla https://muslimscientist.net/ was founded by a group of Muslim scientists committed to bridging the gap between modern science and Islamic principles. By publishing articles grounded in peer-reviewed scientific research, we aim to contribute to the advancement of civilization while remaining true to the ethical and spiritual framework of Islam.

Support & Contact: Us

muslimscientistnet2025@gmail.com

Sign Up for Daily Newsletter

Name
Email
The form has been submitted successfully!
There has been some error while submitting the form. Please verify all form fields again.