Home / Islam Worldwide / Muslim International Students Face Unexpected Religious Challenges in Indonesia

Muslim International Students Face Unexpected Religious Challenges in Indonesia

Summary

A study published in Discover Education has revealed a surprising finding: sharing a religion with the host country does not guarantee an easy adjustment for international students. The research, conducted by scholars at Indonesian universities, interviewed 21 Muslim international students from 14 countries studying in Indonesia—the world’s largest Muslim-majority nation. The results challenge a common assumption that Muslim students moving to a Muslim country will naturally feel at home.

Instead, participants reported navigating unexpected differences in worship routines, gender interaction norms, and local expectations of “correct” Islamic practice. Students from Central Asia, South Asia, Africa, and the Middle East discovered that Indonesian Islam—shaped by distinct jurisprudential traditions and local culture—often differed from what they learned at home. One Kyrgyz student was surprised that Indonesian Muslims emphasized obligatory prayers while treating recommended (sunnah) prayers as optional, the reverse of his home experience. A Pakistani student observed the opposite: Indonesians practiced the voluntary tarawih night prayers during Ramadan as though they were mandatory.

The study, led by researchers affiliated with Indonesian institutions, used semi-structured interviews lasting 60 to 90 minutes, conducted between June and September 2025. Participants included 11 men and 10 women, mostly postgraduate students, with residence in Indonesia ranging from 4 to 120 months. Four major themes emerged: variations in religious practices, identity and gender norms, adaptation and tolerance, and expected institutional support.

The findings carry practical implications for universities. Students said they needed better orientation on Islamic diversity in Indonesia, stronger peer community networks, and organized support during religious holidays to reduce isolation. Many arrived expecting religious familiarity and instead found themselves negotiating unfamiliar norms—from handshaking customs to prayer styles.

For ordinary readers, the study offers a window into a rarely discussed reality: religious diversity exists within Islam itself, and it shapes daily life in ways outsiders often miss. Indonesia’s Islamic landscape is not monolithic. Different schools of jurisprudence, local traditions, and cultural interpretations create a rich but sometimes confusing environment for visitors.

The research also extends academic literature beyond its usual focus on Muslim students in Western, Muslim-minority countries, where Islamophobia and lack of prayer spaces dominate discussions. By studying a Muslim-majority host, the authors show that intra-religious difference can be just as demanding as inter-religious difference. Shared identity, in other words, is not the same as shared practice.

For Indonesian universities pursuing internationalization, the message is clear: recruiting international students is only half the task. Supporting them through religious orientation, community building, and inclusive policies determines whether the experience becomes enriching or isolating. As student mobility continues to grow—from 2.1 million globally in 2000 to over 6 million in 2022—these lessons matter far beyond Indonesia’s borders.


Full article

A Surprising Finding About Religious Familiarity

When Muslim students choose to study in Indonesia, many expect smooth sailing. After all, Indonesia hosts the world’s largest Muslim population, mosques are everywhere, and halal food is the norm. Yet a 2026 study published in Discover Education found that these expectations often collide with reality. The research, based on interviews with 21 international Muslim students from 14 countries, reveals that a shared religion does not automatically produce easy adaptation. Instead, students negotiate unfamiliar worship routines, differing gender norms, and local interpretations of correct practice . The study is among the first to examine international Muslim students’ religious lives in a Muslim-majority host country, filling a gap in research that has overwhelmingly focused on Muslim-minority contexts like Europe and North America.

How the Study Was Conducted

Researchers used a phenomenological approach to capture lived experiences. They recruited 21 participants through criterion and snowball sampling. Eligibility required self-identification as Muslim, enrollment as an international student in Indonesia, at least three months of residence, and sufficient English proficiency. The sample was nearly gender-balanced: 11 men and 10 women. Most were postgraduate students—10 doctoral and 7 master’s—alongside 3 undergraduates and 1 non-degree student. Countries of origin spanned 14 nations, including Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan, Pakistan, and others across Central Asia, South Asia, Africa, and the Middle East. Residence in Indonesia ranged from 4 to 120 months. Interviews lasted 60 to 90 minutes and were conducted between June and September 2025, with 11 online via Google Meet and 10 face-to-face. Researchers used reflexive thematic analysis, supported by NVivo 12 software, and strengthened credibility through member checking and team-based coding discussions .

Study Participants at a Glance

CategoryDetails
Total participants21 Muslim international students
Gender11 men, 10 women
Countries of origin14
Study levels10 doctoral, 7 master’s, 3 bachelor’s, 1 non-degree
Length of stay in Indonesia4–120 months
Interview format11 online, 10 in-person
Interview duration60–90 minutes
Data collection periodJune–September 2025

Source: Discover Education, 2026 .

Four Themes That Tell the Story

The analysis produced four major themes. First, variations in religious practices emerged as a constant source of surprise. Students compared Indonesian worship routines with what they had learned at home, often through the lens of madhhab—schools of Islamic jurisprudence. A Kyrgyz participant explained: “In Kyrgyzstan, most Muslims are Hanafi. Sunnah prayers are treated almost like mandatory. But in Indonesia, most people only perform the fardh. I was surprised because I thought sunnah would be treated more seriously here” (P2). Conversely, a Pakistani participant observed that Indonesians practiced tarawih, a voluntary Ramadan night prayer, as though it were obligatory. These mismatches created uncertainty and, in some cases, fear of being judged as “incorrect.”

Second, identity and gender norms shaped daily interactions. Participants navigated differences in handshaking customs, mixed-group interaction, and physical distance between men and women. These boundaries carry symbolic weight and require continual negotiation across campus and social settings. Third, adaptation and tolerance described how students adjusted over time, developing strategies to bridge differences without abandoning their own practices. Fourth, expected institutional support captured what universities could do better: orientation on Islamic diversity, peer community networks, and organized support during religious holidays.

Why This Matters Beyond Indonesia

The study’s significance extends far beyond one country. Global student mobility has surged from 2.1 million in 2000 to over 6 million in 2022, with a substantial share coming from Muslim-majority nations . Previous research has documented the challenges Muslim students face in Western countries: Islamophobia, racialization, lack of prayer spaces, and inadequate halal food. Those findings remain important. Yet the new study shows that intra-religious diversity—differences within Islam itself—can be just as demanding as inter-religious difference. When students arrive expecting familiarity, unexpected variation can feel more disorienting than outright foreignness. The authors argue that shared religious identity does not remove adjustment demands automatically, because students still negotiate worship routines, gender interaction norms, and local expectations of correct practice .

For Indonesian universities, the practical takeaways are concrete. International offices should include religious diversity in orientation programs. Peer support networks can reduce isolation. Scheduling flexibility around religious holidays—not just Ramadan but also local observances—helps students feel recognized. The study also notes that Indonesia’s Islamic landscape is shaped by long-standing interactions between jurisprudential traditions and local religious cultures, producing a diversity that is rich but not immediately transparent to outsiders .

Key Challenges and Recommended Support

Challenge ReportedStudents’ Recommended Support
Confusion over prayer styles (sunnah vs. fardh)Orientation on Islamic diversity in Indonesia
Uncertainty about gender interaction normsClear campus guidelines and peer mentoring
Isolation during religious holidaysOrganized community events and support
Feeling judged as “incorrect”Safe spaces for open discussion
Lack of information about local practicesPre-arrival briefings and handbooks

Source: Discover Education, 2026 .

What Ordinary People Can Learn

For non-academic readers, the study offers a useful lesson in humility. We often assume that shared labels—Muslim, Christian, Asian, European—imply shared experience. They do not. Two Muslims from different countries may pray differently, interpret gender norms differently, and celebrate holidays differently. Recognizing this diversity is not a threat to religious identity; it is a more accurate picture of how religion actually lives in the world. For students preparing to study abroad, the takeaway is practical: expect difference even where you expect familiarity, and seek out communities that help you navigate it. For universities everywhere, the message is equally clear: internationalization is not just about recruitment numbers. It is about building environments where students from diverse backgrounds can thrive—religiously, academically, and socially.


Sign Up For Daily Newsletter

Stay updated with our weekly newsletter. Subscribe now to never miss an update!

[mc4wp_form]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Flag Counter

About Us

By the grace of Allah Azza wa Jalla https://muslimscientist.net/ was founded by a group of Muslim scientists committed to bridging the gap between modern science and Islamic principles. By publishing articles grounded in peer-reviewed scientific research, we aim to contribute to the advancement of civilization while remaining true to the ethical and spiritual framework of Islam.

Support & Contact: Us

muslimscientistnet2025@gmail.com

Sign Up for Daily Newsletter

Name
Email
The form has been submitted successfully!
There has been some error while submitting the form. Please verify all form fields again.